i just read the story of Abeer’s rape and murder, as well as the murder of her family, on Alternet. and i have nothing but the ultimate respect for Alternet — one of the few sane voices of our insane times.
but what i’d like to know is when war was ever about anything OTHER than rape and pillage? what happened during the crusades? what happened in rome? what happened when mercenaries popped out of the trojan horse? what happened in the writings of homer? what, for chrissake, happened in half of the bible?
rape. pillage. plunder. the strong taking whatever convenient advantage they could of the weak.
so what’s new about what some (not all) of the GI’s are doing in Iraq? they did it in Vietnam. (again, just some of them, there are always the lieutenant cali’s and the ehren watadas of the world, who are willing to sacrifice their own futures for the sake of justice and, hopefully change — but let’s face it, they are a very, very small minority.)
you give men — and, now, women — guns and the right to run riot, and this is what you get. women, you say? what do i mean by women? well, they may not rape (can’t be easy to rape a man who’s too scared to get it up), but they sure do molest. think Abu Ghraib and Lynndie England.
Lord Acton, in 1887, said “absolute power corrupts absolutely” — and he, as a Lord in the land that was then trying to turn the entire earth into its empire, should know. though god knows the current asshole in the white house now wouldn’t agree. probably wouldn’t even get it.
yet it’s true. even if there were enough supervision, it’s the same problem: the supervisors have absolute power.
so let’s distill. the problem isn’t that people don’t do their wars “properly” — the problem is that people go to war. as long as there is sanctified murder in the name of the state, all these states and countries drawn by imaginary lines on imaginary maps — there will be the raping, and the killing, of teenagers. there will be the bombing of villages that are barely literate enough to understand why a war is going on. there will be the kicking of cutoff enemy heads in a parody of soccer (or football). there will be murder and injustice and torture and acts so obscene they haven’t yet been chronicled. there will be kidnappings and public executions. there will, in this day and age, be internet beheadings in the name of some distant god.
the problem is not the execution. the problem is that the so-called leaders of this world continue to believe that war is an option. until they change their minds, the carnage will continue.
and they have nobody to blame but themselves.


















